Future Fleet Forum 2018: Urban air pollution from road transport, by Dr Gary Fuller, King's College London

Published:  10 March, 2018

It is estimated that particle pollution is responsible for 29,000 early deaths in the UK each year, of which around 3,500 are in London, said Dr Gary Fuller, air pollution scientist at King’s College London. Pollution shortens the lives of all Londoners by 16-18 months on average. Like many European cities, London does indeed have an air quality crisis.

Just how bad is London’s air? Well, the city isn’t yet meeting 2010 targets for NO2 (nitrogen dioxide), and is unlikely to for the next 10-15 years, said Dr Fuller. 2016 data reveals that fewer than half of the sites where measurements were taken achieved their annual mean objective for NO2. Eleven sites recorded twice the legal limit and 24 exceeded the hourly limit. The main source of NO2 pollution is vehicles, especially diesel.

The news is more positive for particle pollution, with all sites below 2020 EU target for PM 2.5. However, only one site achieved the World Health Organisation target.

Why is London failing to control its air pollution? ‘Because there is a disparity between the real-world performance of vehicles and the tests they have to pass,’ said Dr Fuller. He explained that while petrol cars largely follow their lab test performance, this is not the case for diesel. In the worst cases, diesels can emit 14 to 15 times more NOx on the road than in a test. ‘The permitted levels have been reduced, but real-world performance hasn’t really changed. That is why we have made so little progress.’

Euro 6 diesel cars are better, but not good enough. The exception is Euro VI for HGVs, which has delivered a real difference in NOx emissions compared with the Euro 6 vehicle. And one third of London’s roads are actually seeing an increase in NOx.

A key issue highlighted by Dr Fuller is the changing source of particle pollution. While particles from exhaust are generally decreasing, this is offset by an increase of particles from wear and tear on brakes, tyres and roads. The increased use of open disc rather than sealed-drum braking technology is partly responsible, but also heavier vehicles, including electric vehicles, which cause more wear and tear. ‘We are seeing increased pollution from wear particles but there are no policies in place to deal with this,’ said Dr Fuller.

Identifying the most effective strategies for curbing air pollution is difficult. In European cities, the LEZ is the weapon of choice because it restricts access to vehicles on the basis of age. London’s LEZ is Europe’s largest and began in 2008. A comparison of data for HGVs in London and Paris, which is only now introducing an LEZ, shows that these zones do deter older vehicles and therefore work as a traffic measure. However, they are not so effective in terms of air pollution because the newer vehicles – with the exception of Euro VI HGVs – aren’t much better than the older ones that are excluded.

'London’s ULEZ for 2019 is a bold proposal,' said Dr Fuller, but he stressed it should not be viewed as a tax. ‘This is often framed in terms of charging vehicles, but actually it is about discouraging them. We don’t want to tax these older vehicles because that doesn’t help air pollution, we just don’t want them in the zone.’

Given that the age of vehicles is no true indicator of real-world performance, how can fleet operators choose vehicles that positively contribute to the air pollution crisis? Dr Fuller highlighted an index of real-world test data that is being compiled by a company called Emissions Analytics. ‘Procurement departments should look at this and choose vehicles that perform best in the real world. Purchasing habits can help to drive up standards with manufacturers because emissions reduction depends on manufacturers.’

Related Articles

  • Future Fleet Awards: Best road safety initiative 

    Biffa’s campaign to stop dangerous driving on pavements won the Best Fleet/Road Safety Initiative at the 2018 Future Fleet Awards. Biffa municipal health and safety coach Dave West tells LAPV how the scheme has evolved and is now moving beyond the waste sector. Lotte Debell reports.

  • Future Fleet Awards: Most innovative fleet management strategy 

    Leeds City Council won the 2018 Future Fleet award for the Most Innovative Fleet Management Strategy. Terry Pycroft, head of services, tells LAPV about the council’s ambitious plans for a fully alternatively-fuelled fleet and why the award helps keep the momentum going. Lotte Debell reports.

  • Sign up for the 2019 Future Fleet Awards 

    The Future Fleet Awards are returning for 2019, bigger and better than ever before. The event is taking place in the Great Hall of the Guildhall in the City of London on January 23 2019.

  • Avery Weigh-Tronix celebrates 200th birthday party 

    Industrial weighing manufacturers Avery Weigh-Tronix has celebrated 200th birthday party with a Best of British themed bash for employees.

  • Why RVS invests in process, procedures and people 

    Good workshop management isn’t just about costs and savings. Spencer Law, MD of Refuse Vehicle Solutions, told LAPV how to create and maintain an efficient workshop and a happy, productive workforce.

Sign Up

For the latest news and updates from LAPV.






Linkedin

LAPV (Local Authority Plant and Vehicles) is the only UK information source purely dedicated to local authority vehicles and affiliated plant equipment. Appearing four times a year, it offers well-researched technical articles on the latest equipment/technology as well as in-depth interviews with key industry professionals. More...

Facebook

Twitter


All content © Hemming Information Services 2018

Sitemap